Evaluation of DGCS-MAE Initiatives in the Health Sector in Mozambique
La valutazione è stata finalizzata all’analisi di alcuni progetti finanziati dal Governo italiano in Mozambico fra il 2006 e il 2011, a supporto dello sviluppo dei sistemi sanitari locali e delle risorse umane. La valutazione ha esaminato l‘efficienza ed efficacia dei progetti, coinvolgendo esperti settoriali per valutare l’impatto e la sostenibilità rispetto alle istituzioni locali coinvolte.
The evaluation main objective was to produce a comprehensive analysis of the following projects financed by the Italian Government in support of the health sector in Mozambique and implemented in the period 2006 – 2011:
- Sviluppo dei sistemi sanitari locali – Iniziativa di appoggio al Piano di Formazione accelerata dei tecnici sanitari nella provincia di Sofala
- Partecipazione italiana al finanziamento e alla gestione del programma settoriale del Governo Mozambicano per il settore sanitario PROSAUDE
- Sostegno allo sviluppo delle risorse umane nel settore sanitario
- Formazione di medici in Mozambico – Programma di supporto alla Facoltà di Medicina dell’Università Cattolica del Mozambico
Three of the four projects have been implemented directly by the Directorate General of Cooperation and Development of the Italian Ministry for Foreign Affairs (MAE), while one was implemented by the Italian NGO Medici con l’Africa CUAMM.
More specifically, the evaluation exercise aimed to investigate the programme efficiency and effectiveness of the four projects, taking into consideration the DAC criteria and the indications provided by the contracting agency. The appropriateness of the MAE strategy was also taken into consideration in the identification of the recommendations that were provided at the end of the evaluation exercise.
In line with the PuntoSud methodology, the evaluation exercise analysed the project logic and the deviation from the original plan (highlighting changes, and their causes), analysed stakeholder and the project management.
The evaluation exercise included a field survey conducted by three sectoral experts to assess the information collected in Italy and to identify the impact and sustainability of the projects with regard of the local institutions involved (Ministry of Health, Directorate of Health in the two target provinces of Maputo and Beira, the Catholic University of Beira – Faculty of Health Sciences, Training Centres of Maputo and Nhamatanda).
Mozambique
PARTNER
- Lead agency: ICEI
- Ngo ProgettoMondo Mlal
- CoopCulture
- AITR (Italian Association of Responsible Tourism)
- UniMiB (University of Milan – Bicocca)
- RED TUSOCO (Red Boliviana de Turismo Solidario Comunitario)
- RED OEPAIC (Red de Organizaciones Económicas de Productores Artesanas/os Identidad Cultural)
- UNQUI- Universidad Nacional de Quilmes
BENEFICIARI
- 2021 – 2022
PROJECT BUDGET
EUR 14.794.533
YEARS
2012 – 2014
SECTORS OF INTERVENTION
Basic services/Infrastructure, Capacity building and professional training, Health/Healthcare
SDGs
LA STORIA DEL PROGETTO
2016 - 2018: Doniamo Energia 1
PARTNER
15 consorzi finanziati
- Lead agency: ICEI
- Ngo ProgettoMondo Mlal
- CoopCulture
- AITR (Italian Association of Responsible Tourism)
- UniMiB (University of Milan – Bicocca)
- RED TUSOCO (Red Boliviana de Turismo Solidario Comunitario)
- RED OEPAIC (Red de Organizaciones Económicas de Productores Artesanas/os Identidad Cultural)
- UNQUI- Universidad Nacional de Quilmes
BUDGET PROGETTO
5555 EURO
2016 - 2018: Doniamo Energia 1
PARTNER
15 consorzi finanziati
- Lead agency: ICEI
- Ngo ProgettoMondo Mlal
- CoopCulture
- AITR (Italian Association of Responsible Tourism)
- UniMiB (University of Milan – Bicocca)
- RED TUSOCO (Red Boliviana de Turismo Solidario Comunitario)
- RED OEPAIC (Red de Organizaciones Económicas de Productores Artesanas/os Identidad Cultural)
- UNQUI- Universidad Nacional de Quilmes
BUDGET PROGETTO
5555 EURO
2016 - 2018: Doniamo Energia 1
PARTNER
15 consorzi finanziati
- Lead agency: ICEI
- Ngo ProgettoMondo Mlal
- CoopCulture
- AITR (Italian Association of Responsible Tourism)
- UniMiB (University of Milan – Bicocca)
- RED TUSOCO (Red Boliviana de Turismo Solidario Comunitario)
- RED OEPAIC (Red de Organizaciones Económicas de Productores Artesanas/os Identidad Cultural)
- UNQUI- Universidad Nacional de Quilmes
BUDGET PROGETTO
5555 EURO
-
€100.000
valore progetto
-
125
alunni della scuola primaria
-
250
genitori
-
20
insegnanti
CONSOLIDATING: OTHER PROJECTS
Fight against energy poverty: evaluation of the Doniamo Energia Calls
Through the evaluation of the Bandi Energia (Energy Call for Proposals), promoted by Fondazione Cariplo and Banco dell’Energia, we contribute to the development of intervention models finalised at avoiding that disadvantaged families in the Lombardy descend into structural poverty. We do this by focusing on promoting skills and territorial networks.
School and gender stereotypes: an innovative intervention model
With the Be.St. – Beyond Stereotypes project we promote the development of a systemic approach across primary schools in order to facilitate relationship building amongst children based on respect and the acknowledgement of diversity in order for future generations to become more aware of their potentials.
Strengthening of emergency medical services in the City of Beira
UR-Beira: strengthening of emergency medical services in the City of Beira is a project funded by the Italian Agency for Development Cooperation (AICS) in Mozambique and coordinated by Veneto Region, aimed at strengthening the emergency health services managed by local authorities in the district of Beira, with a particular focus on obstetric and paediatric emergencies.
PuntoSud was assigned the independent external – mid-term and final – evaluation of the three-year project UR-Beira: strengthening of emergency medical services in the City of Beira (AID 012314/02/6), funded by AICS and coordinated by Veneto Region. The project is implemented in Mozambique and involves – as partners – Medici con l’Africa CUAMM, University Ca’ Foscari, Pia Opera Croce Verde di Padova, Central Hospital of Beira, Serviço de Emergência Médica de Moçambique (SEMMO) e Serviço Distrital de Saúde, Mulher e Acção Social da cidade da Beira (SDSMAS).
The project started on 1st February 2022 and is aimed at aimed at strengthening the emergency health services managed by local authorities in the district of Beira, with a particular focus on obstetric and paediatric emergencies.
The evaluation exercise will be carried out thanks to the involvement of the largest number of stakeholders, with the aim to ensure the quality and the usefulness for the contracting authority (and the project partners) of the reports that will be drafted and submitted.
In particular, the assignment includes the elaboration and the submission of:
- inception report, within 45 days from the conclusion of the contract. The document describes the methodology that will be followed during the implementation of the evaluation exercise, as well as the evaluation team and the workplan.
- Mid-term and final evaluation reports, respectively within 30th September 2023 and 31st December 2024. In both cases, the document shall be composed of an executive summary and of the detailed description of the evaluation carried out.
The evaluation reports will be drafted in line with the OECD/DAC evaluation criteria, as encompassed and applied by AICS, as per DGCS guide for the impact evaluation of development cooperation projects (November 2020).
Mozambique
PARTNERS
- Medici con l’Africa CUAMMS
- Università Ca’ Foscari
- Pia Opera Croce Verde di Padova
- Ospedale Centrale di Beira
- Serviço de Emergência Médica de Moçambique (SEMMO)
- Serviço Distrital de Saúde, Mulher e Acção Social da cidade da Beira (SDSMAS)
BENEFICIARIES
- Staff of the central hospital of Beira and of the 4 health facilities; population of the district of Beira (in particular women and children)
PROJECT BUDGET
1.369.865,4 EUR
ANNO
2021 – 2024
SECTORS OF INTERVENTION
Health/Healthcare
SDGs
LA STORIA DEL PROGETTO
2016 - 2018: Doniamo Energia 1
PARTNER
15 consorzi finanziati
- Lead agency: ICEI
- Ngo ProgettoMondo Mlal
- CoopCulture
- AITR (Italian Association of Responsible Tourism)
- UniMiB (University of Milan – Bicocca)
- RED TUSOCO (Red Boliviana de Turismo Solidario Comunitario)
- RED OEPAIC (Red de Organizaciones Económicas de Productores Artesanas/os Identidad Cultural)
- UNQUI- Universidad Nacional de Quilmes
BUDGET PROGETTO
5555 EURO
2016 - 2018: Doniamo Energia 1
PARTNER
15 consorzi finanziati
- Lead agency: ICEI
- Ngo ProgettoMondo Mlal
- CoopCulture
- AITR (Italian Association of Responsible Tourism)
- UniMiB (University of Milan – Bicocca)
- RED TUSOCO (Red Boliviana de Turismo Solidario Comunitario)
- RED OEPAIC (Red de Organizaciones Económicas de Productores Artesanas/os Identidad Cultural)
- UNQUI- Universidad Nacional de Quilmes
BUDGET PROGETTO
5555 EURO
2016 - 2018: Doniamo Energia 1
PARTNER
15 consorzi finanziati
- Lead agency: ICEI
- Ngo ProgettoMondo Mlal
- CoopCulture
- AITR (Italian Association of Responsible Tourism)
- UniMiB (University of Milan – Bicocca)
- RED TUSOCO (Red Boliviana de Turismo Solidario Comunitario)
- RED OEPAIC (Red de Organizaciones Económicas de Productores Artesanas/os Identidad Cultural)
- UNQUI- Universidad Nacional de Quilmes
BUDGET PROGETTO
5555 EURO
-
€100.000
valore progetto
-
125
alunni della scuola primaria
-
250
genitori
-
20
insegnanti
CONSOLIDATING: OTHER PROJECTS
Fight against energy poverty: evaluation of the Doniamo Energia Calls
Through the evaluation of the Bandi Energia (Energy Call for Proposals), promoted by Fondazione Cariplo and Banco dell’Energia, we contribute to the development of intervention models finalised at avoiding that disadvantaged families in the Lombardy descend into structural poverty. We do this by focusing on promoting skills and territorial networks.
School and gender stereotypes: an innovative intervention model
With the Be.St. – Beyond Stereotypes project we promote the development of a systemic approach across primary schools in order to facilitate relationship building amongst children based on respect and the acknowledgement of diversity in order for future generations to become more aware of their potentials.